Disclosure: Spirit of the Castle is an Amazon Associate/Amazon Influencer which earns from qualifying purchases. This blog post may contain affiliate links. This means that, at no additional cost to you, I will earn an affiliate commission if you click through the link and finalize a purchase.

I already mentioned in my blog post: Pirate Night Outfit Ideas with Pieces found on Amazon, that Pirate Night ( which occurs on select Disney Cruises) is one of my favorite things about a Disney Cruise. One thing that Disney Cruise did that night was serve a Pirate Theme Dinner. It is one of my favorite menus. So I thought I would share the Disney Cruise Pirate Night Menu in my newest blog post. I would say that the menu is Caribbean/Tropical-inspired with some pirate theming.

Pirate Night Menu is served at both dinner times on Pirate Night at each restaurant that is part of the rotational dining.

Disney Cruise Pirate Night Menu

Details of this Menu are from my Disney Cruise on the Disney Magic in February 2023.

Disney Cruise Pirate Night Menu

Specialty Drinks/Cocktails have an additional cost while everything else is included in the price of your cruise. Also, you can order as much food as you want again all included in the price of the cruise.

Appetizers

  • Sri Summbbajee’s Vegetable Samosa
    • with Potatoes, Peas, Garlic, Cumin, and Ginger served with Tamarind and Mint Chutney
  • Angelica’s Lime Marinated Shrimp
    • with Chili, White Corn, Sweet Potato, and Onion
  • Deep Fried Calypso Crab Cake
    • with Cajun Remoulade, Green Onion, and Lemon
  • Swann’s Red and Yellow Beetroot Carpaccio
    • with Asparagus, Pickled Radishes, Cornichons, and Mustard Dressing

Soups and Salads

  • Carrot and Cilantro Soup
    • with Banana Bread Croutons
  • Chilled Mango Soup
    • with Passion Fruit, Ginger, and Coconut
  • Fennel, Orange, and Quinoa Salad
    • with Saffron, Pine Nuts, and Pomegranate
  • Baby Gem
    • with Blue Cheese, Radish, Cherry Tomato, Shallots, Sweet Pecans, and Thousand Island Dressing

Bread Service

  • Johnny Cake
    • with Mango Dip
Disney Cruise Pirate Night Menu

Main Course

  • Jack’s Treasure of the Seas
    • Grilled Shrimp and Seared Scallops served with Spinach, strings of Pasta, Tomato Provençal Sauce
  • Cortes’s Cilantro Marinated Caribbean Grouper Filet
    • on Curried Rice served with Mango, Lime, Avocado, Red Onion, and Black Bean Salsa
  • Tia Dalma’s Jerk Chicken
    • 48-hour Jerk- Marinated Chicken that is Grilled and served with Rice and Peas, Fried Plantains, and a Pineapple-Chili Salsa
  • Chevelle’s Lamb Shank
    • Rosemary Lamb Shank Slowly Braised in Red Wine Served with Buttered Green Beans and Parsnip Mash
  • King George’s Roasted Privateer Strip Loin
    • with Thyme-Roasted Potatoes, Buttered Savory Cabbage, Yorkshire Pudding, and a Rosemary Wine Sauce

Vegetarian

  • Shanghaied Noodle Stir-fry
    • Egg Noodles with Nori, Edamame Beans, White Soy Sauce, Marinated Tofu, Scallions, Peppers, Carrots, and Sesame Seeds
  • Barbary Coast Falafel
    • Fried Ground Cumin Chickpeas with Spiced Vegetables and a Mint Yogurt

Lighter Note

  • Braised Barbecue Beef Rib Salad
    • slowly Brasied Barbecue Beef Rib with Romaine Leaves, Spinach, Macadamia Nuts, Carrots, Roasted Corn Kernels, and Shallots served with Cornbread and a Tomato Sour Cream Dressing
  • Grilled Grain-fed Sirloin Steak
  • Slow-roasted Beast of Chicken
  • Oven-Baked Filet of Salmon

The above 3 entrees are served with Garden Vegetables and your choice of White Rice or Baked Potato

Disney Cruise Pirate Night Menu

Desserts

  • Bounty Fruit Cobbler
    • with Vanilla Ice Cream
  • Bananas in Paradise
    • layered Banana Bread with Hazelnut Fudge Filling served with a Banana Spice Purée
  • Rum-Soaked Chocolate Cake
    • with Raspberry Glaze and Whipped Cream
  • Pirate’s Treasure Sundae
    • Pineapple’ n Coconut Ice Cream, Pineapple, Whipped Cream, Florentine Chard

Signature Dessert

  • Caramel Macadamia Nut Cheesecake Tart
    • served with Whipped Cream and Caramel Ganache

No Sugar Added Dessert

  • Coconut Créam Flan
    • served with Tropical Fruits

Specialty Drinks

(Avaiable at an Additional Cost)

  • Specialty Cocktails (listed above the appetizers)
    • Pirate’s Nest
      • Starr Rum, Mango Ginger Green Tea, and Ginger Beer
    • The Pearl
      • Vanilla Ice Cream with Cherry and Lychee Fruits (Non-Alcoholic)
  • Coffee
    • Espresso
    • Latte
    • Mocha
    • Cappuccino
  • After Dinner Liqueurs
    • Amaretto
    • Cointreau
    • Franelico
    • Amarula Cream
    • Baileys Irish Cream
    • Sambuca
    • Tia Maria
    • Grand Marnier
    • Godiva Chocolate
    • Pama Pomegranate
  • Cognacs & Eaux dé Vié
    • Rémy Martain V.S,O.P,XO
    • Louis XIII Rémy Martin
    • Armagnac
    • CourvoisierV.S,O.P,XO
    • Hennessy Paradis Extra
    • Grappa
  • Dessert Wines & Port Wines
    • Apple Icewine, Quebec, Canada
    • Quinta do Noval 10 year Tawny
    • Quinta do Noval 20 year Tawny
Disney Cruise Pirate Night Menu

Disney Cruise Pirate Night Kids’ Menu

Not only does the Pirate Night Kids’ menu have some activities to do on it, but it can be worn as a pirate hat which I think is a fun little souvenir to commemorate the night which is included in the price of the cruise. Our magical waiter gave us some even though no kids were in our group. So do not be afraid to ask for some if you want the Kids’ menu.

Adults can order off the Kids’ menu. My husband who is a picky eater normally does when we are on the Disney Cruise.

To Start

  • Boson’s Cream of Chicken Soup
  • The Pirates Freshly Cut Garden Salad
    • with your favorite choice of dressing

For the Main Event

Entrees served with fresh Vegetables and your choice of Smashed Potatoes or Steak Fries

  • Totally Carved Sirloin of Beef
  • Mac ‘n Cheese
  • Crusty Cheese Pizza

A Sweet Finish

  • Buccaneer’s Warm Chocolate Brownie
    • Fudge Brownie, Chocolate Chip Cookie center, and Vanilla Ice Cream
  • Mickey Bar Ice Cream
  • Selection of Assorted Ice Cream

Disney Check Meals

  • Grilled Chicken Skewers
    • Entreé: Grilled Chicken Skewer, Roasted Sweet Potatoes, and Broccoli Florets
    • Dessert: Fruit Salad
  • Pasta
    • Entreé: Whole Wheat Penne Pasta with Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese, and Broccoli Florets
    • Dessert: Apple Slices

Smoothie of the Day

(Avaiable at an Additional Cost)

A Look at the Items I Ate from the Disney Cruise Pirate Night Menu

Here are pictures of the items I had from the Pirate Night Menu. I love everything and it was one of the best meals I had on the cruise. Only thing is that I think the Baby Gem salad could have used some more Thousand Island Dressing.